Page 1 of 2

Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 7:50 pm
by Dr_bee
Seriously, someone reached 18,873,400,000,000C on the escape shuttle by pumping fusion into the distro.

Tungsten vaporizes at 5930C the surface of a class O star is only around 49726.85.

The canister should vaporize before even getting near that point.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 8:51 pm
by Ghilker
Once i reached 4*10^30 K in a canister. You can't put logic in a game, otherwise many things that are present should be removed, like if you go to space with a shirt only you die in 2 seconds because you should literally explode from the inside due to the low pressure

Also fusion in distro takes time to enter the station, and if someone see that (AI, an engi, an atmos tech), you can react quickly enough to secure some places by shutting down/welding vents and scrubbers preventing the flooding effectively

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 8:57 pm
by Dr_bee
Ghilker wrote:Once i reached 4*10^30 K in a canister. You can't put logic in a game, otherwise many things that are present should be removed, like if you go to space with a shirt only you die in 2 seconds because you should literally explode from the inside due to the low pressure

Also fusion in distro takes time to enter the station, and if someone see that (AI, an engi, an atmos tech), you can react quickly enough to secure some places by shutting down/welding vents and scrubbers preventing the flooding effectively
I am not talking about adding logic, Im talking about adding sanity. temperature of the kind being generated cant really be fixed through normal means such as space heaters and burn through even the suits designed to be immune to heat damage!

I am not talking about adding realism, im talking about balancing fusion temps around sane temperatures.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 9:17 pm
by Ghilker
is fusion, what is a sane temperature for you?

also is already balanced as it takes a long time to make all the required stuff to produce a "low" temperature fusion

also also the suits are not immune to heat, they are heat resistant. Is normal to have a certain threshold above that even hardsuits burn up

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 9:36 pm
by Dr_bee
Ghilker wrote: also also the suits are not immune to heat, they are heat resistant. Is normal to have a certain threshold above that even hardsuits burn up
So why is a heat threshold on hardsuits reasonable but a heat threshold on walls, pipes, and canisters unreasonable?

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 10:09 pm
by CPTANT
fusion in distro is like an invisible wall of death going through the station.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 10:56 pm
by Ghilker
Dr_bee wrote:
Ghilker wrote: also also the suits are not immune to heat, they are heat resistant. Is normal to have a certain threshold above that even hardsuits burn up
So why is a heat threshold on hardsuits reasonable but a heat threshold on walls, pipes, and canisters unreasonable?
Walls let heat pass if it's high enough (even rwalls), but if you make a threshold for canisters you effectively lock out atmos from making fusion because no one will take the risk of doing it just for it to explode on your face. And even if you put a limit, what for? The lowest temperature will still be very much letal and it doesn't change much between 1*10^8 and 1*10^20 K in terms of lethality

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Mon Jul 22, 2019 11:24 pm
by Cobby
Then don't do fusion if you can't take on the risks.

Those numbers are absurd.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Tue Jul 23, 2019 12:37 am
by NoxVS
Cobby wrote:Then don't do fusion if you can't take on the risks.

Those numbers are absurd.
The problem is usually the guy doing it is fine with the risks, but the rest of the station doesn't really have a choice if the station suddenly becomes hotter than a star and everyone dies instantly.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Tue Jul 23, 2019 1:29 am
by PKPenguin321
Cobby wrote:Then don't do fusion if you can't take on the risks.

Those numbers are absurd.
bruh have u seen some of the busted shit people have been doing with it lmao
the complaint is not "waah its too risky" even a little bit

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Tue Jul 23, 2019 3:54 am
by oranges
Im not sure this is feedback, it's just that most canisters pipes and other atmos sinks and sources are made of an unobtainum that can contain the heat and pressure of the entire universe without rupturing

Someone is free to add burst and leak interactions and stuff

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Tue Jul 23, 2019 3:55 am
by oranges
Personally I wanted to see fusion require powered shielding to actually do, seeing as temperatures at those heat levels should destroy ordinary materials that the station is made out of (immediately venting to space)

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2019 7:55 pm
by Anonmare
I unironically suggested wall melting in the past and ya'll laughed at me.

Also if you care about the station, make your reactor in space - you don't need blueprints to create rooms, only to edit existing ones. I kind of wish there was a TEG so you could use fusion's heat to power the station

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2019 9:16 pm
by oranges
first of all, there is a teg, but personally I thin it's better if the supermatter generated heat and pressure gases that was then piped into turbines, that actually generated the station power

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Thu Jul 25, 2019 9:55 pm
by Cobby
PKPenguin321 wrote:
Cobby wrote:Then don't do fusion if you can't take on the risks.

Those numbers are absurd.
bruh have u seen some of the busted shit people have been doing with it lmao
the complaint is not "waah its too risky" even a little bit
sorry my post was in response to "if you make it risky no one will do fusion" post.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Jul 26, 2019 12:59 am
by MisterPerson
oranges wrote:Personally I wanted to see fusion require powered shielding to actually do, seeing as temperatures at those heat levels should destroy ordinary materials that the station is made out of (immediately venting to space)
That's a bit of an understatement. Here's the boiling point of a bunch of metals. Not the melting point, the boiling point. As in gaseous aluminum is achieved at 2467C. Not that I'm strictly speaking making a realism argument or anything, just generally agreeing extreme temperatures should absolutely have some nasty effects that are not solved simply by venting the hot gas. Think melted electronics, equipment, etc.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Jul 26, 2019 2:36 am
by Dr_bee
MisterPerson wrote:
oranges wrote:Personally I wanted to see fusion require powered shielding to actually do, seeing as temperatures at those heat levels should destroy ordinary materials that the station is made out of (immediately venting to space)
That's a bit of an understatement. Here's the boiling point of a bunch of metals. Not the melting point, the boiling point. As in gaseous aluminum is achieved at 2467C. Not that I'm strictly speaking making a realism argument or anything, just generally agreeing extreme temperatures should absolutely have some nasty effects that are not solved simply by venting the hot gas. Think melted electronics, equipment, etc.
Like I mentioned before, we are seeing temperatures that are several hundred times hotter than the surface of the hottest star. Not only is that silly from a realism standpoint it makes fixing the problem impossible, as the current tools at the crews disposal cant cool the area fast enough to matter.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Jul 26, 2019 3:45 am
by deedubya
Dr_bee wrote:
MisterPerson wrote:
oranges wrote:Personally I wanted to see fusion require powered shielding to actually do, seeing as temperatures at those heat levels should destroy ordinary materials that the station is made out of (immediately venting to space)
That's a bit of an understatement. Here's the boiling point of a bunch of metals. Not the melting point, the boiling point. As in gaseous aluminum is achieved at 2467C. Not that I'm strictly speaking making a realism argument or anything, just generally agreeing extreme temperatures should absolutely have some nasty effects that are not solved simply by venting the hot gas. Think melted electronics, equipment, etc.
Like I mentioned before, we are seeing temperatures that are several hundred times hotter than the surface of the hottest star. Not only is that silly from a realism standpoint it makes fixing the problem impossible, as the current tools at the crews disposal cant cool the area fast enough to matter.
I'm pretty sure uncontained fusion is meant to be a round ending event. Just like a singuloth or a tesloose, fusion in the halls is going to end the round.

Not that I don't agree that seeing 20 zeroes in fusion temperature readouts is horrifically retarded, though.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sun Jul 28, 2019 7:19 am
by Yakumo_Chen
deedubya wrote: I'm pretty sure uncontained fusion is meant to be a round ending event. Just like a singuloth or a tesloose, fusion in the halls is going to end the round.

Not that I don't agree that seeing 20 zeroes in fusion temperature readouts is horrifically retarded, though.
At least with a singulo or tesla you can see what's killing you, or at least make some sane attempt to avoid it.

Fusion gas pumps through the entire station pipe network and has the potential of killing everyone, at once. Just releasing it straight into the air in the center of the station also has the same effect.

There's also not much risk to the actual user since they're likely one of the few people that will know what's going to happen / how to avoid it, wherea singulo and tesla often kill the releaser unless they fuck off to another Z level.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sun Jul 28, 2019 8:07 pm
by Davidchan
Ghilker wrote:You can't put logic in a game, otherwise many things that are present should be removed, like if you go to space with a shirt only you die in 2 seconds because you should literally explode from the inside due to the low pressure
That's literally not how it works. Yes, you'd die with exposure, and vacuum conditions can cause severe damage to soft tissue, you would not explode. Accidents at NASA have shown that people can survive several minutes in near-vacuum conditions, though you pass out after 15 or so seconds without an oxygen supply. With an oxygen tank and some heavy clothing (like a firesuit) you could survive a space walk with no serious damage, though the experience would be unpleasant to say the least. The very idea that we'd explode in low pressure is laughable at the idea that we would implode or flatten at pressures 2-5 times an Earth Atmosphere.

As for the topic at hand, it'd definitely be in the best interest of the game for Canisters, Pumps, Scrubbers and even piping to have maximum limits of pressure and heat they can contain. Perhaps a blue space Canister science could create that would actually allow those ridiculous high temperatures and pressures. May even need to add an actual plasma matter state where gases that reach a certain temperature point convert into a very noticeable cloud of burning gas, even if its just something cosmetic like a green or purple fire effect.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sun Jul 28, 2019 8:56 pm
by lmwevil
if there was a state where air was so hot that it became a special sprite overlay to indicate it's fusion/plasma hot that'd probably be sane. or give us the firelocks that baycode has to see atmos on the other side so you know you're gonna be husked in seconds if you open it

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sun Jul 28, 2019 10:06 pm
by MisterPerson
Could also change air alarms so you can tell what the problem is at a glance rather than just a generic warning or danger.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sun Jul 28, 2019 11:32 pm
by oranges
I dont' agree fusion should be round ending, we have plenty of round enders already.

heat and pressure of that magnitude should always immediately vent into space

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2019 12:06 am
by deedubya
oranges wrote:I dont' agree fusion should be round ending, we have plenty of round enders already.

heat and pressure of that magnitude should always immediately vent into space
Is it time for melting walls, then? If so, I'd recommend having the melting point be something that realistically is only possible through fusion(or thermite usage) so it's primary purpose winds up being as a safeguard against fusion temp flooding.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2019 12:22 am
by Shadowflame909
Fusion has husked an ASHDRAKE IN 3 SECONDS. a being with 2500 health and 50% burn resistance being husked by fusion in 3 seconds

It also instant kills the legion 3x over at round-end.

This is some wild junk.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Aug 02, 2019 5:02 am
by Dr_bee
You can cause the infinate radiation death radius with fusion again by dumping it into the SM. This causes a temp overflow, making the SM think its as cool as possible while the radiation it produces is -inf. This kills anyone walking within a significant ever expanding radius instantly.

The numbers involved in fusion are so high they are causing fucking overflow bugs. Its time to stop.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sat Aug 03, 2019 1:36 pm
by Davidchan
The easiest short term solution would be to have a maxheat on gases or what have you parallel to maxcap for bombs.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Wed Aug 14, 2019 10:07 pm
by Critawakets
Lets be real if a high-tier fusion reaction's gas escapes into space with that kind of heat, the star system that SS13 is in will get a MUCH higher ambient temperature in space, along with it being PRESSURIZED.

Alright but seriously, these temperatures and pressures are so high that it makes balancing the TEG (and therefore power) basically impossible. We cant have a PTL because power is so easily broken.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Wed Aug 14, 2019 11:25 pm
by Screemonster
Ghilker wrote:Once i reached 4*10^30 K in a canister.
push it a little further

see if you can get it past the planck temperature

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2019 9:49 pm
by NecromancerAnne
Last night, we had a round where someone's fusion setup on Pubby cooked the gas in atmos, which also cooked space and the spaceloop for the SM.

The result was everyone on the station dying, the supermatter going thermonuclear and us having to rush the end of the round

This was by complete accident and simply having the gas be present in atmospherics. This is getting absolutely fucking stupid.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2019 10:07 pm
by oranges
so fix it?

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Wed Sep 25, 2019 7:23 pm
by Reyn
For refrence someone managed to get a flame so hot that the fucking flame color value overflowed from white to a bit over pitch fucking black, and examining it with stuff crashed the game, as stated by another thread. We're officially breaking reality.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Wed Sep 25, 2019 9:02 pm
by oranges
I really don't understand why people persist in bumping this thread.

The answer as I have repeatedly stated is to give melting and bursting points to all canisters, pipes and turf/walls and add some kind of magnetic or powered containment for doing fusion.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Thu Sep 26, 2019 3:28 am
by Anonmare
WYCI

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:29 am
by deedubya
WYCI isn't really a solution for gamebreaking issues like this. Everyone knows the problem, and you've even proposed a solution, yet none of the contributors or maintaners seem to want to implement it. Maybe it's time for a feature freeze so that the codebus works on bugfixes, optimization, and solving major gamebreaking issues such as this? This thread in particular has been around for well over two months yet fusion floods are still a semi-regular occurrence. It's ridiculous.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 4:50 am
by carshalash
Apparently fusions insane temperatures and station wiping radiation which can be obtained in the first 30 minutes of the round is here to stay. Fun

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 6:24 am
by actioninja
deedubya wrote:WYCI isn't really a solution for gamebreaking issues like this. Everyone knows the problem, and you've even proposed a solution, yet none of the contributors or maintaners seem to want to implement it. Maybe it's time for a feature freeze so that the codebus works on bugfixes, optimization, and solving major gamebreaking issues such as this? This thread in particular has been around for well over two months yet fusion floods are still a semi-regular occurrence. It's ridiculous.
When you code it.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:03 pm
by Shadowflame909
The reason you don't see bug fix freezes is because they don't trust that tracker


Rip sandbox and Morph forever.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:48 pm
by Reyn
Deathmix fusion canisters can make an entire Z level uninhabitable, Husking corpses in medbay all the way from fucking atmos. And that would be... Semi OK if it were an antag thing only, but no. THIS SHIT IS MADE BY NONANTAGS CONSTANTLY. STOP THIS.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 9:52 pm
by oranges
deedubya wrote:WYCI isn't really a solution for gamebreaking issues like this. Everyone knows the problem, and you've even proposed a solution, yet none of the contributors or maintaners seem to want to implement it. Maybe it's time for a feature freeze so that the codebus works on bugfixes, optimization, and solving major gamebreaking issues such as this? This thread in particular has been around for well over two months yet fusion floods are still a semi-regular occurrence. It's ridiculous.
When you code it

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 10:59 pm
by Cobby
Shadowflame909 wrote:The reason you don't see bug fix freezes is because they don't trust that tracker


Rip sandbox and Morph forever.
what does this mean?

We don't trust the number of issues as a good indication of how broken/fixed the game is.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sat Sep 28, 2019 12:24 am
by Sandshark808
Cobby wrote:
Shadowflame909 wrote:The reason you don't see bug fix freezes is because they don't trust that tracker


Rip sandbox and Morph forever.
what does this mean?

We don't trust the number of issues as a good indication of how broken/fixed the game is.
The modes got dumped because nobody would fix the bugs caused by new features.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sat Sep 28, 2019 1:01 am
by PKPenguin321
oranges wrote:I really don't understand why people persist in bumping this thread.

The answer as I have repeatedly stated is to give melting and bursting points to all canisters, pipes and turf/walls and add some kind of magnetic or powered containment for doing fusion.
When you code it

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Sat Sep 28, 2019 1:52 am
by Shadowflame909
cobblestone das the same thing but differently worded

I'm going to code a brown cow out of anger

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Wed Oct 02, 2019 4:29 pm
by Reyn
We had a fucking plasmaman called "Delamination XXL" decide to turn the station's oxygen supply chamber into a fusion chamber and relied on other people to make a power source there, and just "Expected" viro to make anti rad stuff.

"Lol whats the problem with turning the station's oxygen supply into a new sun"

That shit melted through the walls of the supply.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Wed Oct 02, 2019 8:24 pm
by Oldman Robustin
It wouldn't be THAT hard to tamp down the reaction formulas to bring them down to more realistic levels.

The most sensible solution to me would be to just have stupidly high temps melt the floor (unless its reinforced). Space gives the fusion gas a good succ and the problem kinda resolves itself. People trying to wipe the station would at least have to try to strike a balance instead of just going full throttle on making the hottest gas possible.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Wed Oct 02, 2019 8:57 pm
by Sandshark808
Oldman Robustin wrote:It wouldn't be THAT hard to tamp down the reaction formulas to bring them down to more realistic levels.

The most sensible solution to me would be to just have stupidly high temps melt the floor (unless its reinforced). Space gives the fusion gas a good succ and the problem kinda resolves itself. People trying to wipe the station would at least have to try to strike a balance instead of just going full throttle on making the hottest gas possible.
Or at the very least they would need to build an ultra-secure containment room with reinforced floors and plasma windows/r-walls which limits the ability for idiots to "accidentally" release the gas.

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 1:39 am
by deedubya
Oldman Robustin wrote:It wouldn't be THAT hard to tamp down the reaction formulas to bring them down to more realistic levels.

The most sensible solution to me would be to just have stupidly high temps melt the floor (unless its reinforced). Space gives the fusion gas a good succ and the problem kinda resolves itself. People trying to wipe the station would at least have to try to strike a balance instead of just going full throttle on making the hottest gas possible.
The issue is that fusion temps are so hot and so abundant that they can literally heat the entire z-level to unlivable levels. Yes, that includes the vast open space surrounding the station, nevermind single tiles exposed to space.

also holy shit an oldman post in current year

Re: Fusion temperatures are getting a little stupid.

Posted: Thu Oct 03, 2019 9:34 am
by oranges
Oldman Robustin wrote:It wouldn't be THAT hard to tamp down the reaction formulas to bring them down to more realistic levels.

The most sensible solution to me would be to just have stupidly high temps melt the floor (unless its reinforced). Space gives the fusion gas a good succ and the problem kinda resolves itself. People trying to wipe the station would at least have to try to strike a balance instead of just going full throttle on making the hottest gas possible.
wtf I thought you were dead man

also stop repeating what i already said.