Melee Weapon Rebalance

For feedback on the game code and design. Feedback on server rules and playstyle belong in Policy Discussion.
Post Reply
User avatar
sinfulbliss
Joined: Thu Apr 04, 2019 8:53 am
Byond Username: SinfulBliss
Location: prisoner re-education chamber

Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by sinfulbliss » #626285

Non-traitor melee weapons are pretty unbalanced. Now that combat knives are removed, we are in a weird situation where surgery and engineering tools are the best non-traitor melee weapons in the game.

The strongest is by far the surgical drill. It fits in a bag, does 15 brute, has an extremely high chance of giving open puncture pierce wounds (bloodloss) and eye damage. Most of all, can be printed dirt cheap en masse from the medbay protolathe. Anyone who walks into medbay storage can acquire one.

At second place you have the circular saw (also a surgical tool and printable en masse), which lacks the stronger wounding capabilities but can decapitate (15 brute/hit).

At third place you have a welder, which causes the very problematic burn wounds, ignores armor, is extremely easy to acquire, and fits in a toolbelt (15 burn/hit).

And then below all of these you have the survival knife, the only melee weapon that's actually meant to be a melee weapon, but does only 15 brute with a low wound chance. Even worse is that it needs to be specially ordered from cargo to acquire. It shouldn't be the case that security's best option for getting a melee weapon is to go to medbay and get a surgical drill.

Another problem is the captain's sabre. Although it has a high block chance and great armor piercing, it does a measly 15 brute/hit. For a sword that requires the entire belt slot, which the cap could use instead for his telebaton, it should do at least 18-20 brute. Especially since it's the only weapon of its kind, and unique to the captain. The fact you can kill someone faster with a wielded spear (18 brute/hit) is really bad. I've seen many captains lately simply giving the sabre away, along with the excess items in their garment bag, because it's not worth the belt slot to them.

Finally, the bone axe, which can be easily crafted after 2 minutes in lavaland, and does 23 brute/hit. The same damage as the metal H2 axe that would take an extremely skilled atmos tekkie over 20 minutes to create.

Thoughts?
Spoiler:
Image
Image
Image
User avatar
Shadowflame909
Joined: Mon Jun 05, 2017 10:18 pm
Byond Username: Shadowflame909
Location: Think about something witty and pretend I put it here

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Shadowflame909 » #626286

We need to buff weapons that are dual-wield, hard to craft, and take up slots/cant fit in bag. Like the chainsaw, spear, Chairs.

Nerf stuff that is easily storable and easy to get. Like surgical drills, Hatchets/Kitchen Knives, Screwdrivers.

It should be a sliding scale of the more obvious, the more dangerous.
► Show Spoiler
User avatar
Pandarsenic
Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2014 11:56 pm
Byond Username: Pandarsenic
Location: AI Upload

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Pandarsenic » #626301

Mostly agreed, though remember you can instantly craft a chair if you carry metal with you.
(2:53:35 AM) scaredofshadows: how about head of robutts
I once wrote a guide to fixing telecomms woohoo
User avatar
bastardblaster
Joined: Fri Oct 23, 2020 10:57 am
Byond Username: BastardBlaster
Location: Ionia, Runeterra

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by bastardblaster » #626302

i'd like more alternative attacks for weapons, like that one PR which gave the captain's saber a dash attack, or Axes letting you charge up for a sec for a power attack in a circle around you
Image

Image

Image

Image
User avatar
Super Aggro Crag
In Game PermaBanned
Joined: Sat Mar 21, 2015 9:47 pm
Byond Username: Super Aggro Crag

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Super Aggro Crag » #626358

Man i just want to kill people dont nerf my weapons
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
User avatar
oranges
Code Maintainer
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2014 9:16 pm
Byond Username: Optimumtact
Github Username: optimumtact
Location: #CHATSHITGETBANGED

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by oranges » #626378

really big job.
User avatar
Rohen_Tahir
Joined: Wed Jun 05, 2019 1:00 pm
Byond Username: Rohen Tahir
Location: Primary fool storage
Contact:

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Rohen_Tahir » #626418

for you
Image
Longestarmlonglaw
Joined: Fri Jan 14, 2022 7:42 am
Byond Username: Longestarmlonglaw

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Longestarmlonglaw » #627410

re add combat knives
User avatar
nianjiilical
In-Game Admin
Joined: Sun Sep 29, 2019 2:30 am
Byond Username: Nianjiilical

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by nianjiilical » #628720

instead of asking what weapons need to be nerfed, i think the better questions to ask should be

a) what should be the "standards" by which weapons are judged? i think the fire axe is in a good position as the high end but rare weapon, and the op seems to posit 15 brute being "intentional weapon" tier, so should weapons be balanced around the notion of "15 is gold standard, 10~ is silver, 5-8 is bronze"?

b) how much are other attributes "worth" compared to raw damage? the surgical drill is currently the meta weapon because it has 15 damage plus high wounds, but i would argue that the drill itself isn't inherently imbalanced so much as it's just better than the alternatives. how much should it be nerfed to keep it "as powerful" as a 15 damage no wound bonus weapon? would 12 damage + wound bonus be "equal" to 15 damage + no wound bonus? 10 damage? and how does this stack up to other potential benefits weapons have? is 15 burn damage as powerful as 15 brute? does 10 burn = 15 brute?

for what its worth i think that the current weapon meta isnt horrifically imbalanced, in the sense that the drill isn't op, its just better than the alternatives, but to bring it in line with the alternatives means figuring out what "the line" should be
human: ramon chivara
ai: shitpost generator
borg: shite-115
clown: donk tonkler
mime: beautiful noise

admin feedback thread

my admin policy:
Spoiler:
Image
User avatar
Ayy Lemoh
Joined: Mon Jun 05, 2017 5:58 pm
Byond Username: Jerry Derpington

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Ayy Lemoh » #628729

Quit making the game a fucking esport.
User avatar
Pandarsenic
Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2014 11:56 pm
Byond Username: Pandarsenic
Location: AI Upload

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Pandarsenic » #628733

What are toolboxes, extinguishers, and thrown floor tiles at right now?
(2:53:35 AM) scaredofshadows: how about head of robutts
I once wrote a guide to fixing telecomms woohoo
User avatar
NecromancerAnne
In-Game Admin
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2018 6:55 pm
Byond Username: NecromancerAnne
Location: Don't touch me, motherfucker...

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by NecromancerAnne » #628775

Pandarsenic wrote: Fri Feb 04, 2022 4:09 pm What are toolboxes, extinguishers, and thrown floor tiles at right now?
In order: 12 force and throw force, 10 force and throw force, and 10 throw force.
User avatar
Pandarsenic
Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2014 11:56 pm
Byond Username: Pandarsenic
Location: AI Upload

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Pandarsenic » #628778

Honestly, those values aren't awful for things you can carry in a pack for toolbox/floor tiles.

I almost feel like the toolbox, maaaybe, might be worth touching up a little since you can't put it in a backpack. As a container, it's inferior to a toolbelt or just a normal box, and as a weapon it's vastly inferior to a fire extinguisher, its own contents (the welder), or to other departmental tools (drill, saw, etc.) despite only being suitable to hold in hand.

Also I'm a boomer, toolbox memes from the old days when knockdown was death, etc.
(2:53:35 AM) scaredofshadows: how about head of robutts
I once wrote a guide to fixing telecomms woohoo
User avatar
NecromancerAnne
In-Game Admin
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2018 6:55 pm
Byond Username: NecromancerAnne
Location: Don't touch me, motherfucker...

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by NecromancerAnne » #628780

We do have a new way in which to balance weapons in the form of wounds. Raw damage isn't necessary if you can use a weapon to cause a wound and hobble an opponent. Not every fight is necessarily to the death (even if people will push for it), and sometimes you're simply wounding someone to humble them.

On the flipside, I think a lot of these weapons are mostly opportunistic and environmental and less something you necessarily equip with you long term. I think focusing more on the environmental aspect of weapons might make for some more interesting dynamics, which I think is a niche melee tends to fill separate from gunfights.

Stuff like chairs, pot plants, bottles and the like being things you employ opportunistically to catch someone by surprise, but ultimately become useless as a weapon afterwards by just breaking. Adding to that, making these a little clunky to use as prepared weapons would go a long way. I think bottles are already pretty good for what they do at the moment as a good example of an environmental weapon.
Dopamiin
Joined: Tue Jul 14, 2020 11:30 am
Byond Username: Dopamiin

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Dopamiin » #628786

i didnt know about the drill but that does seem too strong, a lot of other shit feels like its in an okay spot right now.

welding tools and saws are fine imo, they're strong but not beyond what i feel they should be for a usually known about weapon (anyone with a toolset or doctors)

i thought survival knifes did 20 brute? imo 18 would be a safe spot as an easily-concealable crew-oriented, but somewhat hard to get item that's deliberately a weapon (as opposed to some of the others)

sword is fine, blockchance is insanely good and captain shouldnt be getting into fights, their telebaton is better as an emergency tool, though i wouldnt complain about a damage buff

bone axes arent a problem, you cant get them without either going out of your way or asking a miner to and they're a wielded, crafted weapon that you have to hold. stunprods are better and easier to get imo, and spears serve the niche of strong but very easy to make wielded weapon. anything that's a backslot only should be allowed to be good because all of them are unhideable and require advanced prep (you really dont want to be sitting there crafting a weapon while someone's trying to beat you to death)

really the drill is literally the only thing that worries me here (as a source of eye damage which can be very scary on top of already having good base stats)
plays on manuel
User avatar
Helios
Joined: Mon May 05, 2014 5:07 pm
Byond Username: Shodansbreak

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Helios » #628796

NecromancerAnne wrote: Sat Feb 05, 2022 12:21 am We do have a new way in which to balance weapons in the form of wounds. Raw damage isn't necessary if you can use a weapon to cause a wound and hobble an opponent. Not every fight is necessarily to the death (even if people will push for it), and sometimes you're simply wounding someone to humble them.

On the flipside, I think a lot of these weapons are mostly opportunistic and environmental and less something you necessarily equip with you long term. I think focusing more on the environmental aspect of weapons might make for some more interesting dynamics, which I think is a niche melee tends to fill separate from gunfights.

Stuff like chairs, pot plants, bottles and the like being things you employ opportunistically to catch someone by surprise, but ultimately become useless as a weapon afterwards by just breaking. Adding to that, making these a little clunky to use as prepared weapons would go a long way. I think bottles are already pretty good for what they do at the moment as a good example of an environmental weapon.
I disagree. Wounds don't make the game more fun.
We would be better off going to a way older meta of 2007, where toolboxes had a lot more knockdown. Where someone could kill you by repeatedly knocking you down with their toolbox, removing your headset and welding you into a locker, or just using the welder to finish the job with damage.
Toolboxes were innoucous, and also a potential deadly weapon. As a detective if I saw a blood stain on the floor and a missing locker, I knew something was afoot. Sure, there's changes, a lot more noise someone can make if they're stuck in a welded locker, but it was a better time.
User avatar
oranges
Code Maintainer
Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2014 9:16 pm
Byond Username: Optimumtact
Github Username: optimumtact
Location: #CHATSHITGETBANGED

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by oranges » #629082

shut the fuck up boomer
User avatar
Armhulen
Global Moderator
Joined: Thu Apr 28, 2016 4:30 pm
Byond Username: Armhulenn
Github Username: bazelart
Location: The Grand Tournament

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Armhulen » #629088

Shadowflame909 wrote: Thu Jan 20, 2022 4:07 am We need to buff weapons that are dual-wield, hard to craft, and take up slots/cant fit in bag. Like the chainsaw, spear, Chairs.

Nerf stuff that is easily storable and easy to get. Like surgical drills, Hatchets/Kitchen Knives, Screwdrivers.

It should be a sliding scale of the more obvious, the more dangerous.
i like this idea
User avatar
Pandarsenic
Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2014 11:56 pm
Byond Username: Pandarsenic
Location: AI Upload

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Pandarsenic » #629163

Same, but also keep in mind that certain powergamers (what no not me shhh) know dirty tricks like keeping half-assembled spears in their bags with shards to just make spears on the spot

You can do similar with chairs.

The final step of crafting those could stand to be a little slower, probably, if they're buffed as weapons (which they should be)
(2:53:35 AM) scaredofshadows: how about head of robutts
I once wrote a guide to fixing telecomms woohoo
User avatar
NecromancerAnne
In-Game Admin
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2018 6:55 pm
Byond Username: NecromancerAnne
Location: Don't touch me, motherfucker...

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by NecromancerAnne » #629660

Craft menu makes anything non-combat viable. :shades:

(Or just add do_afters craft menu I know isn't particularly liked for how it works)
User avatar
Kendrickorium
Joined: Wed Feb 13, 2019 1:00 am
Byond Username: Kendrickorium

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Kendrickorium » #629673

I find that without my saber or a gun, the ol toolbox always does the trick

the surgical saw has ALWAYS been a go-to for me

why not just leave everything alone because it all feels fine to me
Image
User avatar
Farquaar
Joined: Sat Apr 07, 2018 7:20 am
Byond Username: Farquaar
Location: Delta Quadrant

Re: Melee Weapon Rebalance

Post by Farquaar » #629675

Balance is not really the issue. I'd much rather combat be made interesting, rather than balanced.

In my opinion, combat should be fast and deadly. Ambushes should be the typically resolve in favour of the attacker. If an improvised weapon could easily kill a man in real life, it should be able to easily kill a man in SS13. The main advantage of swords, axes, or spears should be that they make you better able to defend against melee attacks (more range, parrying, wider "arc of attack"), rather than magically deal more damage.

If I had my way, you would be allowed to kill Mr. Body in the dining room with the candlestick so long as his back was turned. And if he was facing you and holding a sword, you wouldn't have many defensive options other than fleeing or somehow disarming him.
► Show Spoiler
Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users