[Mr Melbert] Contextualizing Noted Behavior

Appeals which have been closed.
Locked
Y0SH1M4S73R
Joined: Sun Nov 29, 2015 10:50 pm
Byond Username: Y0SH1_M4S73R
Github Username: Y0SH1M4S73R

[Mr Melbert] Contextualizing Noted Behavior

Post by Y0SH1M4S73R » #622533

BYOND account: Y0SH1_M4S73R
Character name: Speaks-Her-Mind
Ban type: Note
Ban length: N/A
Ban reason: After being converted to revolutionary, then being promoted to head revolutionary, walked up to sec and outed themselves. The revolution was still in full swing so doing this greatly harms your team - please work with your team more in the future.
Time ban was placed: 2021-12-18 02:01:26
Server you were playing on when banned: Manuel
Round ID in which ban was placed: 174977
Your side of the story: I had been flashed and promoted to revhead by a bumrushing initial revhead who was caught almost immediately afterwards. Security was already securing cargo for mindshields at the time of my promotion, and I did not know that there was a third revhead as I had not seen them yet. Due to these factors, I erroneously assumed that the revolution was basically over, and that it would be easier to turn myself in then get round-removed. Upon being informed about the third revhead, who wasn't in custody, I stopped attempting to surrender, and made an honest attempt at carrying out a revolution.
Why you think the note should be amended: The note reason fails to address the fact that I assumed the revolution was imminently doomed, and the fact that I immediately went back to making a good faith effort for the team when I knew it wasn't basically already over.
User avatar
mrmelbert
In-Game Game Master
Joined: Fri Apr 03, 2020 6:26 pm
Byond Username: Mr Melbert

Re: [Mr Melbert] Contextualizing Noted Behavior

Post by mrmelbert » #622549

Hey there, thanks for appealing this note, but I don't really intend on amending the note any.

Here are the relevant logs from the round:

First, you are flashed and converted into the revolution, and shortly after converted to a head revolutionary.
Within the next 3 minutes, the head revolutionary who flashed you who was caught, and you immediately decide to give yourself up - despite there being quite a number of revolutionaries (8+) and another headrev still out there. Even if you didn't know there was another headrev out there, it's kind of your duty to go out and convert people, not jump the gun and surrender on the spot.

Code: Select all

[2021-12-18 01:47:15.822] GAME: 01:47:15.822] GAME: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) has gained antag datum Revolutionary(/datum/antagonist/rev) 
[2021-12-18 01:47:29.539] SAY: 01:47:29.539] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "Oh how fucking unsurprising." (Diner (149,134,4)) 
[2021-12-18 01:47:32.745] GAME: 01:47:32.745] GAME: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) has gained antag datum Head Revolutionary(/datum/antagonist/rev/head) 
[2021-12-18 01:51:48.177] SAY: 01:51:48.177] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "I didn't ask to have 'Kill Me'; literally tattooed on my forehead. Just launch us both on the gulag shuttle and back and we can get this over with without bloodsheed." (Fore Primary Hallway (111,164,4)) 
[2021-12-18 01:55:16.894] SAY: 01:55:16.894] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "I'm a head because that guy flashed me." (Fore Primary Hallway (104,164,4)) 
(It's also worth noting the first headrev that was caught wasn't even executed on the spot, but exiled and eventually made their way out to freedom. You were even there watching as they exiled the first headrev through the security windows - there wasn't any real reason to assume the revolution was "imminently doomed" by this point. This is largely why I don't feel like the note needs to be amended.)

After you outed yourself, I step in and tell you that you shouldn't out yourself like that as a headrev, as it works against your team.
You agree, grab the flash from tech storage, and flash one person.

Code: Select all

[2021-12-18 02:05:31.902] ATTACK: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) has flashed(targeted) Carshalash/(Scrubs-The-Everything) with the flash (NEWHP: 100)  (Port Primary Hallway (63,142,4))
15 minutes after your conversion, a detective asks you to come along to the brig willingly, to which you comply (not even being cuffed).

Code: Select all

[2021-12-18 02:20:28.649] SAY: 02:20:28.649] SAY: KaiserWilly2/(Friedrich Von Luetke) "Speaks" (Port Primary Hallway (83,140,4)) 
[2021-12-18 02:20:31.767] SAY: 02:20:31.767] SAY: KaiserWilly2/(Friedrich Von Luetke) "Please come with me" (Port Primary Hallway (83,140,4)) 
(Note that in the 25 minutes between when you outed yourself and this point, you didn't communicate with any team members or even seek out the remaining final headrev (who was still alive, free, and converting people at the time).
This is quite evident of poor team-play, which is why a note was placed.)

You arrive in the brig un-cuffed and allow them to exile you (until eventually, an officer decides to execute you).

Code: Select all

[2021-12-18 02:20:45.722] SAY: 02:20:45.722] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "Only on the condition that I am not killed." (Port Primary Hallway (83,140,4)) 
[2021-12-18 02:23:00.062] SAY: 02:23:00.062] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "Listen. I didn't choose to be a head. I'm only one because of that casket-stuffer over there." (Brig (119,170,4)) 
[2021-12-18 02:23:48.563] SAY: 02:23:48.563] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "I was going to leave of my own volition, but higher forces suggested I not." (Brig (118,170,4)) 
[2021-12-18 02:24:07.995] SAY: 02:24:07.995] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "Now that you've got me, there should be no harm in me fucking off into the wilderness." (Brig (118,170,4)) 
[2021-12-18 02:24:54.490] SAY: 02:24:54.490] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "Perma... isn't quite how it works with heavrevs. I have to get put on the shuttle." (Brig (116,170,4)) 
[2021-12-18 02:25:26.501] SAY: 02:25:26.501] SAY: Y0SH1_M4S73R/(Speaks-Her-Mind) "At least let me have that stuff back once centcom declares this whole ordeal over." (Brig (111,170,4)) 
In my eyes, this is very poor team-play, and while I do appreciate that you attempted to get into the swing of the revolution after I asked, I wouldn't necessarily say it was the grandest-faith attempt at I've seen.

Ultimately, I don't feel like this note needs to be amended any. It was placed as evidence that you had issues cooperating with your team after being converted. It's worth mentioning that the note itself is minor severity due to the fact that you have a very clean note history and you were understanding about the situation when I approached you about it.
Admin: December 2020 - Present
Code Maintainer: December 2021 - Present
Head Admin: Feburary 2022 - September 2022
Youtube Guy: sometimes


Image
Locked

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users