What meaningful damage was caused that they are responsible for? Nobody died and nothing important was broken. From what I could tell they were responsible for maybe a light fixture and a third of an airlock door until the shuttle left, and zero deaths.
Zero deaths perhaps, but this is not something we would like to see on the MRP server on top of inexcusable constant negligence as evidenced by their history.
I was the one who suggested they appeal this ban. This specific statement just reinforces my thought that this is a pretty spite-driven ban.
Your opinion, not fact. I suggest you forgo any psychological analysis based off of a single ban appeal. The player in question has been noted/banned by twelve different admins, excluding myself.
Also for reference: from what I saw, this was the total size of the fire at its absolute largest (until after the shuttle left, dunno if it reignited at that point)
It was not, it flooded the entire departures area with plasma. You should know gas moves evenly, it wouldn't just stay and cover that small area you depicted.
A small fire was released after a traitor broke the containment i build over them, this is a cool interaction and part of the story of the round. a small fire is fun for the crew. you seem to be assuming bad faith in my play. in reality im just a fucking idiot, most of my notes are due to incompetence.
Fun is subjective, but rules and responsibility are not. Assuming bad faith in play here is irrelevant. I don't really have an opinion about you, this is purely off the situation that happened and your note/ban history. We cannot let things slide because of your excuse of being incompetent, we have no realistic way of completely verifying if you are doing it on purpose or not, but we can track problematic behaviors and apply necessary decisions we would rather not like to do.
The perverse incentives created here for antags to disassemble even slightly-harmful contraptions in order to get people in trouble are pretty hilarious, but also extremely chilling for antagonists who want to commit sabotage without risking other people getting banned for it.
It's as simple as not creating a hazard in a public area. If you want to make virology as a virologist into uranium hell, go for it as it's not in a public area and people will have to go out of their way to give themselves stage 4 cancer. This is different as the plasma chamber was made in departures as the shuttle was arriving.
If I'd known the other player was going to get BANNED for me breaking out of their chamber as an antag I'd have disassembled my way to space instead, disassembling right instead of left. Making me specifically responsible for this ban sucks ass.
You exploited someone's bad idea to cause a plasmaflood, you chose to do that and if you feel responsible for it, that's not in my place to say otherwise.
As for my incompetence in relation to bad faith play. Alot of people here are idiots. But we are all idiots trying to have fun togethe
It's what makes this game really special
A bit rude to call a lot of other players idiots, but regardless of that, that sort of fun is subjective and not part of the ruling.
In any case, as you have requested headmin review, I will not be replying any further as I must divert my attention elsewhere for a special day tomorrow.
