ArcaneMusic Adam Klein - Fair ban Unfair punishment
Posted: Sat Sep 12, 2020 4:36 am
Byond name: Adam Klein
Character name: Jim Barret
Ban type: General Heads of staff ban
Ban length: One month
Ban reason: Banned from Roles: Captain, Head of Personnel, Head of Security, Chief Engineer, Research Director, Chief Medical Officer for 1 month - Seems to consistently over-escalate situations as a head of staff, even when the situation is already solved. I want you to really study up on how escalation works, it doesn't mean you can't defend yourself, it means you need to defend yourself in-kind to the threat at hand.
Time ban was placed: 2020-09-12 00:23:44
The server you were playing on when banned: Bagil
Your side of the story: Well, the shift started as any other shift as the CMO starts. I was doing my job, collecting tools for a medical belt and I found someone, I'm sorry can't remember the name for the life of me, Going through my stuff in my office. Being that the CMO is often a target due to being the least defended head of staff round start, Naturally, I was scared. Also, bagil is notorious for having a greytide problem. So, I ask the person what the hell they are doing in my office. I get no response and they continue digging through my stuff. This is the part that I imagine the administrator took issue with, but I then proceeded to flash the intruder and put them in a soft crit in order to prevent the possibility of a retaliation attack. My team and I then brought the intruder back to full health, being that we are doctors after all. This started a blood feud between myself and this other person that would last untill the end of the round.
Why you think you should be unbanned: Well, I'm not arguing for a total unban, because I can see why this could be considered over-escalation, but on that same hand, with the exception of a note in may "Which was not as a head roll, mind you" I have shown no consistent over escalation as to support a ban of this lenght. Bringing this to head, I motion to have either the ban revoked for the heads of staff that were not played this shift, or a reduction in the amount of time of the total ban.
Character name: Jim Barret
Ban type: General Heads of staff ban
Ban length: One month
Ban reason: Banned from Roles: Captain, Head of Personnel, Head of Security, Chief Engineer, Research Director, Chief Medical Officer for 1 month - Seems to consistently over-escalate situations as a head of staff, even when the situation is already solved. I want you to really study up on how escalation works, it doesn't mean you can't defend yourself, it means you need to defend yourself in-kind to the threat at hand.
Time ban was placed: 2020-09-12 00:23:44
The server you were playing on when banned: Bagil
Your side of the story: Well, the shift started as any other shift as the CMO starts. I was doing my job, collecting tools for a medical belt and I found someone, I'm sorry can't remember the name for the life of me, Going through my stuff in my office. Being that the CMO is often a target due to being the least defended head of staff round start, Naturally, I was scared. Also, bagil is notorious for having a greytide problem. So, I ask the person what the hell they are doing in my office. I get no response and they continue digging through my stuff. This is the part that I imagine the administrator took issue with, but I then proceeded to flash the intruder and put them in a soft crit in order to prevent the possibility of a retaliation attack. My team and I then brought the intruder back to full health, being that we are doctors after all. This started a blood feud between myself and this other person that would last untill the end of the round.
Why you think you should be unbanned: Well, I'm not arguing for a total unban, because I can see why this could be considered over-escalation, but on that same hand, with the exception of a note in may "Which was not as a head roll, mind you" I have shown no consistent over escalation as to support a ban of this lenght. Bringing this to head, I motion to have either the ban revoked for the heads of staff that were not played this shift, or a reduction in the amount of time of the total ban.