/tg/Station 13

Please post any positive or negative feedback for the administrator here.
This is not the place to discuss ban appeals, admin complaints, or ban requests.
This is for specific feedback for this administrator.

Has been absorbing the admin tools and the lingo like a freaking sponge. They are able to handle themselves really well in ahelps and doesn't panic to ask questions.

Really happy they accepted the offer and became a part of the team!

Glad to hear, I'm glad to be working with the community. I will not waste this opportunity. Any and all feedback is greatly appreciated.

Overall an extremely kind and understanding admin. A nice, cool headed respite on the usually hectic basil.

Forgot to do this when he actually accepted the event, but coffee hopping on to let me (and the crew) nuke with a clown who had a nuke core inside him was pretty nice. Big mcthankies on that one.

Active on the discord and nice to talk to there too, so that counts, I guess?

Whenever I see them adminning they are handling tickets well or causing some sort of mischief in the best way. Great person to have on the team and a positive force in the bus.

I get in a lot of arguments on different rule interpretations but they're a good admin. We need more coffees.

Has been a consistent and dependable source of policy and information - a great help as I get used to adminning! I feel they can be a little too strict at times, but that's not necessarily a bad thing on a server like bagil.

Edit: since posting that I do feel they are just too strict in regards to certain things - however most of them are protected by the rules so it's really just a different view on the game. Good admin overall, just disagree with them on a few things.

mostly negative review
do they ban people who deserve it sometimes? yeah probably
do they ban for the most minute shit? Yes.
most of the recent ban appeals are from coffeedragon, doesnt mean it's a good thing as most of them feel like a giant stretch and sometimes they're just completely fucking stupid
banning somebody for wearing chaplain clothes and using their weed spell is absolutely stupid
noting somebody for refusing to give back a fireaxe and then misinterpreting the entire scenario is absolutely stupid

agree with saprasam, feels like they try to stretch it way too far to get a note sometimes without good reason

Seems like a banbot. Funny note appeals with coffee really reaching for reasons to keep notes. Keep for my amusement. But overall, gets a thumbs down.

can be nice in ahelps, but generally dramaticisizes a lot of the things she bwoinks about
accusations and noting of antag rolling for a single suicide
bans over dchat raging
bans over minute escalation

seems like they target specific players, and generally will note/ban over things that the other admins dont typically give a fuck about enough to even bwoink

as a player i like them a lot, as an admin not so much.

thumbs down

Way too heavy handed for non-roleplay servers

cute

Lied in my appeal multiple times, lacks good administrative investigative skills, and punishes over very inane stuff. Likes to load players with notes so they can catch a ban because "you have a lot of notes". Has given many notes for some truly silly things like:

- giving a chaplain a note for ban baiting because someone killed them thinking they were a wizard while they were wearing chaplain gear https://tgstation13.org/phpBB/viewtopic ... 34&t=28320
- noting bindy for antag rolling after a singular suicide https://tgstation13.org/phpBB/viewtopic ... 34&t=28333
- noting manley for antag rolling after a singular suicide https://tgstation13.org/phpBB/viewtopic ... 34&t=28328

As well as my own notes from them, you can see one of my appeals here https://tgstation13.org/phpBB/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=28346

Overall I am disappointed in this admin's performance, I've brought it up with them in the past and have been met with complete denial. It all feels super personal to me but I have no proof so whatever.

There is nothing wrong with the second and third link you posted, as that's the the only way to track antag rolling behavior unless you personally want to sift through logs or constantly be on the game observing specific people (neither of which are as visible to the player as a note that they can appeal). This is actually great conduct, as the admins view of the player is fully transparent and the users can correct any misconceptions.

Im not sure why you elected to specify the person, if you are suggesting that they should know these people more and make assumptions based off that and therefore not note them unlike a hubbie I would think that would be something you WOULDNT want from an admin, especially considering you think you are a victim of admin bias.

I think a first one was a mistake, so the only conclusion i can get from your post is that they should be more careful in how they word their notes, which I think is safe to say feedback-wise (we could all improve on that i think).

Very tilting admin. Treats server like mediumrp when it is lightrp. Gave a 3 day ban for interfering with shitsec couping captain. Rude in ahelp and uses any note they can find to maximize punishment.

I like this one. Don't really admin alongside them playing on different servers, but their takes on things are very good in general, and they don't seem afraid to bonk people for breaking the spirit of the rules. Lots of good jannie energy.

CruelLordTywin wrote:Very tilting admin. Treats server like mediumrp when it is lightrp. Gave a 3 day ban for interfering with shitsec couping captain. Rude in ahelp and uses any note they can find to maximize punishment.

I would highly recommend opening a complaint if you feel that you were treated unfairly.

Coffeedragon16 has retired.

CoffeeDragon16 has returned

bwoink me angry, gr.

Glad they're back

saved me from A COMA(BUG) WITH FUCKIN A GIB! AND THEN RESPAWNED ME AS JOHNATHAN! IM JONATHON!!!!!

Love em though.

Really happy to see her back as an admin. She’s a great player and an even better admin.

Found a mysteriously missing machine (a very hard-to-spot APC) for me back in 182605, which was cool.

In less concrete and specific terms, an admin I'm always glad to see online when I'm around.

Did a fun little gimmick with me last nukie round when we wanted to do war but the crew was too small. Thank you for doing it when you didn't have to!

10/10 would play a round with them adminning again

It's been very nice to see them around adminning and in the admin backchannels. I feel they have a very good understanding of what high-quality moderation should be.

Coffeedragon16 has retired.