[MRP] What is it about space/mining gear that makes obtaining it not powergame regardless of job?
Posted: Fri Mar 12, 2021 4:52 am
Something that drives me up the wall on manuel is the fact that you get bonked for even taking a stun baton from a beepsky... yet, somehow, it's totally fine for an assistant to beeline for an EVA suit and go to space an grab a fucking 40mm grenade launcher that's capable of insta-critting most people, or an esword, or a stechkin-equivilant, or a literal SYNDICATE BOMB, or so many other things. Or even just going down to lavaland and beelining for tendrils/ruins, without doing any mining whatsoever...
Where do we draw the line? What is it about these sources of gamer gear that make them ok to get? Is it tied to job? Can curator powergame space but not assistants? Can assistants beeline for tendrils and not mine, or can only miners refuse to mine? Are non-miners allowed to get mining gamer gear regardless of anything? Or should miners be forced to mine regardless of anything? There's also the obvious case to make; if we ban non-antags from powergaming space or lavaland, only antags will do this, causing a huge metagame red flag to appear saying "I'M AN ANTAG! I'M AN ANTAG! VALID ME VALID ME VALID ME!". I have no rebuttal. This is true. Which is why I hope this discussion serves to bring to light this inconsistancy in our rules, and maybe even inspire people to pursue code solutions if no satisfactory policy outcome can be achieved.
Also, this isn't me taking a shot at people who enjoy this kinda stuff, that's fine, I just noticed this as a glaring inconsistency in the rules and I want some clarification.
Where do we draw the line? What is it about these sources of gamer gear that make them ok to get? Is it tied to job? Can curator powergame space but not assistants? Can assistants beeline for tendrils and not mine, or can only miners refuse to mine? Are non-miners allowed to get mining gamer gear regardless of anything? Or should miners be forced to mine regardless of anything? There's also the obvious case to make; if we ban non-antags from powergaming space or lavaland, only antags will do this, causing a huge metagame red flag to appear saying "I'M AN ANTAG! I'M AN ANTAG! VALID ME VALID ME VALID ME!". I have no rebuttal. This is true. Which is why I hope this discussion serves to bring to light this inconsistancy in our rules, and maybe even inspire people to pursue code solutions if no satisfactory policy outcome can be achieved.
Also, this isn't me taking a shot at people who enjoy this kinda stuff, that's fine, I just noticed this as a glaring inconsistency in the rules and I want some clarification.