Page 1 of 2

There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-pop

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2016 7:57 am
by Cuboos
Seriously, this shit drives people off. It's different on high pop when it's more likely to have retaliation and there's more sec to do something about it. But the circumstances of low-pop are a lot different. There's less chance to be returned to the game via clone/borg/drone/other. 30 players use to be considered low-pop for /tg/, but now the low-pop hours barely break above 15 and murderboning is definitely the most likely culprit. There has to be something that can be done about it, maybe if the population is at a certain level and there is only so much security, murderboning could be grounds for a temp ban? Or maybe be antag-banned for a few days. Or be placed in a punishment job a few days, like clown or drone.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2016 8:06 am
by oranges
You got lost on your way to the policy subforum

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2016 8:06 am
by oranges
also if you're after pop you should move to basil

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2016 8:24 am
by Steelpoint
Still amused that Sybil is the lower pop server.

Murderboning on low pop can really only be stopped by a competent security force. If someone wants to go on a murder spree on low pop I think that's their prerogative, though I think if there happens to be a admin on (which is never) then they should find a way to bring some dead people back in to stop the murderboner. Some will say that this is rewarding the murderer but I claim that if you do nothing you force most of the server to sit in deadchat for at minimum fifteen plus minutes as they wait for the murderer to kill everyone and call the shuttle, or for someone to stop the murderer eventually and either watch as the round extends for a hour or for the shuttle to be called.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Oct 26, 2016 8:29 am
by Cuboos
i didn't realize there was a policy forum, can an admin move this thread?

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 5:22 pm
by Supermichael777
rampant murder 4norasin used to get you bonked and told not to be such a massive dick. these days you have to purposely recall the shuttle to keep it going to get told off. Antagonists get to ignore the rules has always been the ruling on this.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 5:39 pm
by Slettal
My favorite grudge is still the one player who killed the almost whole station, then suicided and wrote in dead chat "fuck you". He also probably logged off after that. But that is a more a sybil problem since sometimes there aren't even admins online

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 5:45 pm
by Wyzack
Slettal wrote:My favorite grudge is still the one player who killed the almost whole station, then suicided and wrote in dead chat "fuck you". He also probably logged off after that. But that is a more a sybil problem since sometimes there aren't even admins online

[youtube]e7qQ6_RV4VQ[/youtube]

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 6:31 pm
by Cik
yeah, it's shit.

there's barely ever any security in midpop, let alone lowpop and traitorkit is so powerful now it takes more than one.

even if they fuck up AIs can't really stop them anymore due to doorbashing and others of the nonstop nerfs

borgs are also helpless

there's been a gradual reduction of the ability of the station to stop traitors forever, actually.

tl;dr ye agree

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 6:31 pm
by NikNakFlak
ew a necro

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 6:37 pm
by Armhulen
NikNakFlak wrote:ew a necro
still relevant


I think lowpop murder is fine as long as they don't recall the shuttle

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 7:09 pm
by Saegrimr
Armhulen wrote:I think lowpop murder is fine as long as they don't recall the shuttle
I don't mind so much if the shuttle is on its way while they're doing it.

It's the shitnuggets that recall are the ones I spawn 50 spiders on.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 8:22 pm
by John_Oxford
make security roles a force pick then.

then make being incompetent at security (failing to kill x) (abandoning your job at round start) a bannable offense.

reward every confirmed traitor killed with a antag token, then give traitors 60tc.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Nov 29, 2016 10:32 pm
by PKPenguin321
Wyzack wrote:
Slettal wrote:My favorite grudge is still the one player who killed the almost whole station, then suicided and wrote in dead chat "fuck you". He also probably logged off after that. But that is a more a sybil problem since sometimes there aren't even admins online
We don't have any not-american-or-european Sybil admins so it's basically devoid of administration past 10 PM. I find myself solo adminning around 8 PM and forwards almost every time I stay on.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 9:42 pm
by oranges
^ this

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 9:55 pm
by Cobby
oranges wrote:^ this
Is it time for citrusmin?

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 9:59 pm
by Atlanta-Ned
ExcessiveCobblestone wrote:
oranges wrote:^ this
Is it time for citrusmin?
No.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 10:24 pm
by Takeguru
murderbone is fine go away

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 10:39 pm
by TehSteveo
Takeguru wrote:murderbone is fine go away
Not when they murder all six players on a server then gotta wait fifteen minutes before a shuttle may get called. I've seen Sybil die after some murderboner killed everyone which ended up killing any population on it. At that point I'm more inclined to take action as I rather let antags go but when overall health of a server is impacted for one person's jollies it isn't good.

Admins can and have taken action against low-effort lowpop murderboners within reason. Such as their objective isn't hijack and they're just killing everyone without much contest because they can. You leave yourself open to admin intervention at that point which can be ERT/Deathsquad, other antags sent after you, or other things spawned in. Also that behavior can be noted down for people who constantly murderbone when given the chance during lowpop.

Problem is more so we have not many admins on early morning hours which leads to issues. Something I'm aware and trying to address but it's kinda hard being those hours are not the best for me and for a new admin they have to be trained by someone.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 10:50 pm
by onleavedontatme
PKPenguin321 wrote:
Wyzack wrote:
Slettal wrote:My favorite grudge is still the one player who killed the almost whole station, then suicided and wrote in dead chat "fuck you". He also probably logged off after that. But that is a more a sybil problem since sometimes there aren't even admins online
We don't have any not-american-or-european Sybil admins so it's basically devoid of administration past 10 PM. I find myself solo adminning around 8 PM and forwards almost every time I stay on.
We have to have a stupidly large admin team because trying to cover 24/7 uptime for two servers with depressed nocturnal neets doing 12 hour shifts is not sustainable.

Making the servers up for only 12-18 hours a day or only on some days of the week, or just having one server would be nice.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Nov 30, 2016 10:56 pm
by TechnoAlchemist
Kor wrote:
PKPenguin321 wrote:
Wyzack wrote:
Slettal wrote:My favorite grudge is still the one player who killed the almost whole station, then suicided and wrote in dead chat "fuck you". He also probably logged off after that. But that is a more a sybil problem since sometimes there aren't even admins online
We don't have any not-american-or-european Sybil admins so it's basically devoid of administration past 10 PM. I find myself solo adminning around 8 PM and forwards almost every time I stay on.
We have to have a stupidly large admin team because trying to cover 24/7 uptime for two servers with depressed nocturnal neets doing 12 hour shifts is not sustainable.

Making the servers up for only 12-18 hours a day or only on some days of the week, or just having one server would be nice.
Let's do it boys

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 01, 2016 4:51 am
by kevinz000
TehPear wrote:
Takeguru wrote:murderbone is fine go away
Not when they murder all six players on a server then gotta wait fifteen minutes before a shuttle may get called. I've seen Sybil die after some murderboner killed everyone which ended up killing any population on it. At that point I'm more inclined to take action as I rather let antags go but when overall health of a server is impacted for one person's jollies it isn't good.

Admins can and have taken action against low-effort lowpop murderboners within reason. Such as their objective isn't hijack and they're just killing everyone without much contest because they can. You leave yourself open to admin intervention at that point which can be ERT/Deathsquad, other antags sent after you, or other things spawned in. Also that behavior can be noted down for people who constantly murderbone when given the chance during lowpop.

Problem is more so we have not many admins on early morning hours which leads to issues. Something I'm aware and trying to address but it's kinda hard being those hours are not the best for me and for a new admin they have to be trained by someone.
I've seen certain sybil regular(s) murderbone every time they roll antag, and get on bagil and play and still do that when they roll antag. Certain bagil players also murderbone alot when they don't need to but they don't do it all the time. I've been told it's alright unless they only roll for antag and don't play normal rounds.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 01, 2016 5:50 am
by TehSteveo
kevinz000 wrote:
TehPear wrote:
Takeguru wrote:murderbone is fine go away
Not when they murder all six players on a server then gotta wait fifteen minutes before a shuttle may get called. I've seen Sybil die after some murderboner killed everyone which ended up killing any population on it. At that point I'm more inclined to take action as I rather let antags go but when overall health of a server is impacted for one person's jollies it isn't good.

Admins can and have taken action against low-effort lowpop murderboners within reason. Such as their objective isn't hijack and they're just killing everyone without much contest because they can. You leave yourself open to admin intervention at that point which can be ERT/Deathsquad, other antags sent after you, or other things spawned in. Also that behavior can be noted down for people who constantly murderbone when given the chance during lowpop.

Problem is more so we have not many admins on early morning hours which leads to issues. Something I'm aware and trying to address but it's kinda hard being those hours are not the best for me and for a new admin they have to be trained by someone.
I've seen certain sybil regular(s) murderbone every time they roll antag, and get on bagil and play and still do that when they roll antag. Certain bagil players also murderbone alot when they don't need to but they don't do it all the time. I've been told it's alright unless they only roll for antag and don't play normal rounds.
I'm not sure what server has to do with it as it happens on both and generally during our hours of less coverage as they likely feel they can get away with more stupidity. Also, again it's admin discretion for the decision to intervene. Many, including myself, will let it play out to see what happens as sometimes its also the situation. Such as say their hand was forced when someone caught them and crew tried to valid them and failed.

Yet if they're playing hold the station hostage with the shuttle, killing everyone that it ends up making the server desolate place, camping arrivals after killing everyone just for more valids, or a known history of such behavior that they're more or less trying to just be horrible. We can invoke rule zero for the health of the server and intervene as there's killing and then there's killing the server in a very literal matter.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 01, 2016 1:22 pm
by Lumbermancer
The policy should be that online admins have to be more active in fucking murderboners over with memes if things go too far.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 01, 2016 4:36 pm
by Cobby
Daily reminder you can hop on supportbus and speak to [us] about certain players who you notice do this consistently. We may not be able to do anything administratively at the time you report it, but it's good to note down so admins can monitor their behavior when they roll antag [or when they don't they go AFK, etc.].

That or shoot one of us a forum/IRC pm if you're afraid of someone lurking in supportbus, whichever is more convenient for you.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 01, 2016 5:54 pm
by Atlanta-Ned
Or just ahelp it, MAKING SURE to INCLUDE THE NAME OF THE PERSON BEING A PROBLEM.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 4:19 am
by starmute
Cuboos wrote:Seriously, this shit drives people off. It's different on high pop when it's more likely to have retaliation and there's more sec to do something about it. But the circumstances of low-pop are a lot different. There's less chance to be returned to the game via clone/borg/drone/other. 30 players use to be considered low-pop for /tg/, but now the low-pop hours barely break above 15 and murderboning is definitely the most likely culprit. There has to be something that can be done about it, maybe if the population is at a certain level and there is only so much security, murderboning could be grounds for a temp ban? Or maybe be antag-banned for a few days. Or be placed in a punishment job a few days, like clown or drone.

Hey consider taking a log of whats going on. Its helpful!

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 5:54 am
by onleavedontatme
Admins sporadically sending an ERT to fuck with a guy after they've already murdered everyone doesn't usually improve the experience if it's just the same short and pointless death match next ten man round.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 11:52 am
by oranges
if only there was some kind of forum we could post logs of a player doing this and others could also include their logs... hmm

makes you think

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 12:12 pm
by D&B
H-HES NOT PLAYING TRAITOR THE WAY I LIKR ADMINS B-BAN HE

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 3:53 pm
by Armhulen
D&B wrote:H-HES NOT PLAYING TRAITOR THE WAY I LIKR ADMINS B-BAN HE
That's not the problem though, you don't get it because you're a bagillian or something but on Sybil when every round the whole station gets wiped it actually starts to make people not want to play, killing the server

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 4:41 pm
by Wyzack
Yeah, Antags doing whatever they want is good and all, but a low pop total wipe murderboner can literally kill the server population for the night and drive everyone away to do something less frustrating. The consequences last beyond the single shitty round

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 5:26 pm
by Copybass
I've been staying up late on Sybil a lot lately, and using it as a time to try and learn things I haven't been able to in normal rounds; mostly the gunplay and slipping side of SS13 because of the fact that 1 in every 2 players is out to kill you. I appreciate the murderbone in lowpop. I have no issues with it, and I have no issues with being killed as a nontarget just because I was there in an antag's sight - It also means that I have someone to learn from when they're coming at me. When it gets painful is when the rounds go on to 60+ minutes because said player wants more blood that literally doesn't exist outside of a braindead atmotech tucked away in a locker and the ghostroles are nothing worth clicking for the ghosts that have existed from the first five minutes. I've never closed the game over it, but I know a number of people swap back over to Bagil the moment they see it's happening.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 6:18 pm
by D&B
Do restart votes not work anymore?

If everyone gets fed up they should be able to vote to restart.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 6:24 pm
by Copybass
D&B wrote:Do restart votes not work anymore?

If everyone gets fed up they should be able to vote to restart.
Late night restart votes are always 2-5 nos from the 2-5 people who went braindead because they didnt roll antag, 3-4 nos from antags who don't wanna see it end until they get their blood, and then there are sometimes yesses from ghosts but the No always wins by default.

They're also almost always used as a meme by one unnamed player so you can tell exactly when he died in a round.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Fri Dec 02, 2016 6:46 pm
by Wyzack
True brain dead players don't get a vote I don't think, only ones that are still logged on the server

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Sat Dec 03, 2016 1:31 am
by Isane
Don't restart votes still require an admin to actually restart the server?

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Sat Dec 03, 2016 2:09 am
by Wyzack
No, they automatically pass if there are no admins online

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Sat Dec 03, 2016 3:45 pm
by TheNightingale
Rework restart votes so people who don't vote don't count, and having an admin online doesn't autofail it (but they can override if they want to).

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2016 9:28 am
by Arianya
TheNightingale wrote:Rework restart votes so people who don't vote don't count, and having an admin online doesn't autofail it (but they can override if they want to).
This will just lead to outrage as people miss the relatively tight vote window and get the round restarted out from under them. Doubly so if its an action-packed round with bullets flying that dissuades people from stopping to click through the voting interface.

Plus, certain antag objectives like "hijack the shuttle " all but require murderboning and if you make it easier for salt ghosts to restart you might as well remove that objective.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2016 3:14 pm
by Wyzack
Yeah, people counting as no when they do not vote is absolutely by design. It is not supposed to be easy to call a restart vote, and it supposed to be reserved for times when shit is horribly fucked up and there are no admins online. If you can not even get half of the people logged in to click on a little yes button then it is probably not so bad that you can not wait out the shuttle

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Mon Dec 05, 2016 4:43 pm
by Cobby
Instead of Restart, make a force shuttle call with no recall after X% of people die [lowpop only]? That way the murderboner still gets 10 minutes [assuming he has hijack] to finish everyone else off but also allows low pop players a chance to get back into the game relatively soon.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Tue Dec 06, 2016 7:18 pm
by Grazyn
Yeah restart vote must keep its failsafes, if it's made easier people will constantly restart on lowpop when a novelty map is chosen or it rolls extended

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Dec 07, 2016 5:09 am
by Poorman
Oh shit. "IM DED RESTORT" is going to become a real thing.

I miss 2012.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Wed Dec 07, 2016 8:58 am
by TehSteveo
Grazyn wrote:Yeah restart vote must keep its failsafes, if it's made easier people will constantly restart on lowpop when a novelty map is chosen or it rolls extended
In regards to the map the joke would be each restart wouldn't do nothing to resolve that. Less time for the round there's less chance for map rotation to trigger. Restart vote would just restart the server and do nothing.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 08, 2016 4:54 am
by tedward1337
Good god we're still talking about this. I've seen too many threads about this

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 08, 2016 9:56 am
by DemonFiren
Which suggests that it remains a problem.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 15, 2016 12:04 pm
by firecage
Well, we just had a round where there were, at round end, 5 people on, with one dude murderboning everyone. And here's the kicker, he was also killing people as they exited the arrivals shuttle.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 15, 2016 12:06 pm
by DemonFiren
Arrivals camping is bannable, though.

Re: There needs to be a policy about murder boning on low-po

Posted: Thu Dec 15, 2016 12:09 pm
by firecage
Apparently certain people in OOC has no comprehension about what that is.