Page 1 of 1

Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 10:34 pm
by paprika
Okay now that we've added disablers everywhere (cough cough I've added disablers everywhere) and replaced a lot of tasers, I think it's time to remove that old, shitty feature of going slow when you're on lower and lower health.

Why is it shit?

Because not eating already slows you down to a fucking crawl after like 30 minutes. It makes melee combat worse because if someone shoots you at range a few times you're at a huge disadvantage and already as good as dead.

Why would removing it be good?

It would remove the ability for people to kite with ranged lethals.
SECURITY COULD STILL KITE MOBS OF GREYSHIRTS because they have disablers and tasers which are more effective at slowing than lethals anyway.
It would bring back that hyper-violent gameplay where you're never safe just because you have a gun.

ALTERNATIVE SOLUTION:

Only leg limb damage slows you down instead of a total of all damage. Very easy to code. Makes limb targetting matter.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2016 11:54 pm
by Shaps-cloud
Slowdown from low health makes melee easier because it's your only hope of actually managing to chase someone down with your melee weapon. Your suggestion could just as easily fit the other way around where someone who's injured and has a gun can still kite someone with a melee weapon running after them

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 12:09 am
by paprika
No, because melee has built in knockdown RNG and disarms are a thing.

Your real chance of getting someone with a gun is catching up to them and spamming disarm, or trying to get a good hit on their head/chest with the knockdown threshold on higher-damage melee weapons depending on which has a higher chance of occuring (hint, it's disarm)

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 12:33 am
by lumipharon
Yeah that doesn't sound like a good idea.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 1:40 am
by Super Aggro Crag
:honkman: :revolver:

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 2:43 am
by PKPenguin321
this is bad as demonstrated by borgs

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 3:11 am
by Super Aggro Crag
i like paprika even if i think this idea is dumb

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 5:02 am
by paprika
I still don't get why people think this is bad, only shaps has said why he thinks it's bad and allowed me to argue in favor of less easymode ranged combat

But whatever floats your boat I guess, imo any slow accompanied by damage is bad because it's way too easy to get consecutive shots. This isn't as bad when it comes to disablers because they don't deal damage and you have to waste even more energy to laser or get close to beat them when they're down, which takes a lot longer than just lasering someone to death.

Please don't start drama in my thread also.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 1:55 pm
by Cheimon
Catching people going at full speed in melee is surprisingly hard to do. The slowdown is pretty much what lets you finish fights that one person doesn't want to be involved in (otherwise escape is easy and quick). I know some people have really got the hang of it, but the majority of the server hasn't.

People shot up several times before they reach the laserer should be at a disadvantage anyway. That isn't a problem.

You keep assuming that both people want to fight in the scenario and that's not the case for a good 60% of combats in the game. When one person wants to escape, there has to be a mechanic to make escaping harder. It way easier to avoid getting hit than to hit someone.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 2:11 pm
by allura
yikes

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 6:45 pm
by Super Aggro Crag
get your own gimmick, goofball

also i think being hurt should increase your speed as adrenaline floods your body, so that people start bashing themselves with toolboxes so they can sax around sec.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 8:10 pm
by PlaugeWalker
Honestly, the idea is flawed yes but, some refinement can maybe put it to use. I mean yeah the combat kinda is a pain in the ass when it comes to melee but a small movement buff could help out nothing to drastic is all. I think he meant.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Sun May 01, 2016 11:22 pm
by paprika
Cheimon wrote:Catching people going at full speed in melee is surprisingly hard to do. The slowdown is pretty much what lets you finish fights that one person doesn't want to be involved in (otherwise escape is easy and quick). I know some people have really got the hang of it, but the majority of the server hasn't.

People shot up several times before they reach the laserer should be at a disadvantage anyway. That isn't a problem.

You keep assuming that both people want to fight in the scenario and that's not the case for a good 60% of combats in the game. When one person wants to escape, there has to be a mechanic to make escaping harder. It way easier to avoid getting hit than to hit someone.
When one person wants to escape there is a myriad of tools to do it now from improvised bolas to disablers to tasers to morphine syringe gun to bear traps to water spray bottles to soap to bananas

Traitors can get ebows too and this would buff em but I see your point, thanks for the thoughtful reply, I'll reconsider this idea at length

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Mon May 02, 2016 11:57 pm
by Ezel
Hurting arms alot giving a chance to drop their items when
Crippling enemies legs when?

TACTICAL NECK SNAP WHEN

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 3:43 am
by Armhulen
Ezel wrote:TACTICAL NECK SNAP WHEN
breathin heavy with my sleeping carp scroll
this is the setup every round i roll
the other players fun i take a toll
greentext please, i got players to crap
walk up to the window, tap tap
and then i go for the sick neck sna-

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 9:00 am
by paprika
Yeah flat out removing the slowdown might have been a bad idea but maybe I can expand on this idea so combat is fun without being too easy to escape from by yakkety saxing, I dunno

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 6:35 pm
by Topham
i feel like we should nerf the slowdown from some typical types of combat damage, yeah, but not get rid of it completely. i think it should be different for each type of damage, although this may be unnecessarily complicated.
  • historically, people in duels and battles and such would still be full-on swinging even after getting wounded terribly. there's more than enough evidence in this in historical fighting manuals and accounts and such. so brute damage shouldn't slow you down very much, because the adrenaline will keep you going to fight back. optionally, if it would be possible to initially have no slowdown from brute but then later on have the adrenaline wear away, that'd be neat.
  • burns, on the other hand, hurt like a motherfucker and even moreso when you move, so slowdown from burn damage makes some sense, as long as you're not actively still on fire. if you are on fire, then, you would probably even get a buff to speed or something because you're on fucking fire.
  • iirc, toxin damage does slow you down but it also makes you vomit a bunch, which leads to the hunger slowdown and more barfing and eventually you're walking slower than a fucking snail. i'd say that toxin damage should make you vomit, but the slowdown itself without vomiting should be less severe.
  • slowdown from respiratory damage makes sense, probably keep it. starving your brain of oxygen severely impedes fine motor functions and survival instincts.
i dunno, just some thoughts.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 8:19 pm
by Armhulen
Topham wrote:snipperoni
I love the idea of adrenaline from brute damage.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Tue May 03, 2016 10:45 pm
by DrPillzRedux
Keep the slowdown. Make the character move with a limp by having the sprite shake around. Makes it a little harder to hit them.

Re: Remove slowdown from low health (buff melee combat)

Posted: Wed May 04, 2016 2:53 am
by Topham
Armhulen wrote:
Topham wrote:snipperoni
I love the idea of adrenaline from brute damage.
i would love to be a psycho who stabs himself to move faster
DrPillzRedux wrote:Keep the slowdown. Make the character move with a limp by having the sprite shake around. Makes it a little harder to hit them.
make the sprite shake around? like when you're hyper? because human sprites are so large that i feel like hitting it isn't much of a problem, usually