Revenant Policy Regarding Other Antags

[Tunder]

After a few bad experiences with revenants as an antag(getting murdered by their EMP attack as a malf AI, getting ratted out to Sec as an agent by a revenant after letting him feed off critted victims before spacing them), I feel that revenant policy needs to be made more specific.

Revenants should be the antag equivalent of drones, cleaning up after messes but not getting involved in worldly affairs, and it says something along those lines in their flavor text. Their being able to act as hear-all see-all rogue agents who can affect a round at will is questionable, and doesn't seem to fit the point of their existence.

[InsaneHyena]

Agreed. Too often I see revenants deliberately messing with antags, perhaps as some form of metagrudge. I haven't observed your loss specifically, so I can't say anything about this particular round, but I HAVE seen revenants that, for example, forsake their "stay hidden" objective and went loud to break a gang's dominator.

[Tunder]

Agreed. Too often I see revenants deliberately messing with antags, perhaps as some form of metagrudge.

Yeah, I just got metagrudged by Niknakflak, an admin, who helped Sec all round after snagging a few free meals from me. Shit was uncool, and the flavor text when you are made a revenant is pretty specific regarding working with antags and not against em.

An admin spawning himself as an antag that can go everywhere, see everything, and help Sec fuck over other antags is too much.

[TheNightingale]

They're ghosts; why can they talk?

[Scones]

Maybe their ability to speak to humans is just shitty and problematic

[NikNakFlak]

It was a random event. I snagged some free meals from you and then betrayed you because security gave me more meals. There are no sides in revenant, it's whatever you feel like to get your essence points. Throwing out metagrudge claims is rather poor taste just because you are salty.

[Incomptinence]

For the benefit of those who haven't been one what exactly is this stupid flavour text?

[NikNakFlak]

You are a revenant.
Your formerly mundane spirit has been infused with alien energies and empowered into a revenant.
You are not dead, not alive, but somewhere in between. You are capable of limited interaction with both worlds.
You are invincible and invisible to everyone but other ghosts. Some abilities may change this.
To function, you are to drain the life essence from humans. This essence is a resource and will power all of your abilities.
You do not remember anything of your past lives, nor will you remember anything about this one after your death.
Be sure to read the wiki page at https://tgstation13.org/wiki/Revenant to learn more.

[Scones]

and the flavor text when you are made a revenant is pretty specific regarding working with antags and not against em.

You are a revenant.
Your formerly mundane spirit has been infused with alien energies and empowered into a revenant.
You are not dead, not alive, but somewhere in between. You are capable of limited interaction with both worlds.
You are invincible and invisible to everyone but other ghosts. Some abilities may change this.
To function, you are to drain the life essence from humans. This essence is a resource and will power all of your abilities.
You do not remember anything of your past lives, nor will you remember anything about this one after your death
Be sure to read the wiki page at https://tgstation13.org/wiki/Revenant to learn more.

What?

An admin spawning himself as an antag that can go everywhere, see everything, and help Sec fuck over other antags is too much.

Do you have any evidence of this? Shouldn't this be an admin complaint?

[NikNakFlak]

No mention of having to help antagonists in the original PR either: https://github.com/tgstation/-tg-station/pull/8842

[Tunder]

and the flavor text when you are made a revenant is pretty specific regarding working with antags and not against em.

You are a revenant.
Your formerly mundane spirit has been infused with alien energies and empowered into a revenant.
You are not dead, not alive, but somewhere in between. You are capable of limited interaction with both worlds.
You are invincible and invisible to everyone but other ghosts. Some abilities may change this.
To function, you are to drain the life essence from humans. This essence is a resource and will power all of your abilities.
You do not remember anything of your past lives, nor will you remember anything about this one after your death
Be sure to read the wiki page at https://tgstation13.org/wiki/Revenant to learn more.

What?

An admin spawning himself as an antag that can go everywhere, see everything, and help Sec fuck over other antags is too much.

Do you have any evidence of this? Shouldn't this be an admin complaint?

It was apparently changed, fairly certain the spawn text had a sentence regarding working with other antags.

[Boredone]

Kinda minor, but Revenants currently get random fluff objectives, like be non-lethal, help other antags, kill the chaplain, etc.

[Alex Crimson]

I ded nerf pls.

Seriously, a Revenant has basically no way to kill people, so it either flies around being useless waiting for people to die, or it talks people into killing eachother. I see no issues with this as long as the Revenant only snitches on antags it sees after its spawned, not antags it saw as an observer.

[whodaloo]

Alex, revenants can single-handedly murder malfunctioning AIs, and have done so more than once.

[Tunder]

Alex, revenants can single-handedly murder malfunctioning AIs, and have done so more than once.

Whose idea was it to give them EMP when they exist solely to feed off of living humanoids in crit, anyway?

It doesn't make any sense.

[Shad0vvs]

Sometimes they get the objective of

Objective #2: Collaborate with existing antagonists aboard the station to gain essence.

Which you may be confusing for the spawn text.

[lumipharon]

What is even the point of revenants?

They just ghost around griefing people with EMP, then soul suck random people.
They seem functionally (or literally, not sure) invincible and uncounterable. They're just sort of... there. Annoying and inconveniencing people at best, dicking over malf's etc at worst.

R&d needs to be able to some sort of ghost buster backpack to suck them up for science.

[Alex Crimson]

Yeah the EMP thing is silly. No idea why that was added as an ability. All Revenant abilities suck now. It was supposed to be an antag that does spooky/environmental stuff, but i guess Xhuis got bored and moved onto other projects.

[Tunder]

It was a random event. I snagged some free meals from you and then betrayed you because security gave me more meals. There are no sides in revenant, it's whatever you feel like to get your essence points. Throwing out metagrudge claims is rather poor taste just because you are salty.

I'm not salty, I greentexted despite your meddling.

The fact was that you were able and allowed to act the way you did, when you probably shouldn't be.

Shard souls are given the ability to talk and go wherever because they are bound to another antag's will. Ghosts aren't allowed to interact with the game anymore for good reason, they ruin the game for antags. Revenants are apparently given the ability to communicate with living players, which is bullshit to begin with and proven for years to not work with noclipping mob types, but then they're allowed to do whatever they want with the ability to see everything and talk to everyone, which is even more bullshit.

[Alex Crimson]

They cannot do much else though. Talking people into killing eachother is the main way Revenant will get fresh kills. Just because a ghost is talking to you, that doesnt mean you should trust it. Last time i was Revenant i lied to the HoS and told them random people were "evil".

[lumipharon]

They're pretty fucking awful.

Just had a round where badmins made several of them.
Constant fucking emp spam, constant whatever the power is that knocks everyone out for ages with loads of stam damage and burn.