The stickyban system is broken and does more harm than good

[BananaSenor]

Seriously. I have so many good rounds ruined by getting banned by that shit. Please remove it until it works properly, or the server getting brigaded by evil people.

Edit: Honestly, if some people force you to enable a system that randomly bans half the server every few hours, than the terrorists have won. I rather be maxcapped twice a day than getting banned once.

[Lumbermancer]

I'm yet to get banned by this. You just need to get good.

[Aloraydrel]

>every few hours

[AnonymousNow]

Just happened to me. This Slugger person was the target.

[lzimann]

Stickyban is a byond feature and not ours, it's really effective against evaders.

[BananaSenor]

Maybe you guys are not affected, but the server went from 80 to 30 people or so. It is effective against everyone. Is it really worth it? (Honestly, I dont know if its worth it, I dont have the numbers.) Why not have it on a toggle and enable it only when evaders are trying to grief?

[imblyings]

it's a sliding scale between freedom and security

[Alex Crimson]

Ive been banned by the system a few times now, but honestly if the system is actually catching the proper users, then im fine with it. The inconvenience of an occasional ban is nothing if the stickyban actually sticks to the shit player who earned it.

...and im sure if i ever get banned whilst playing an important role, the admins will be gentle, right? RIGHT?

[onleavedontatme]

Better a hundred innocent players get banned than one ban evader go free.

[iamgoofball]

Better a hundred innocent players get banned than one ban evader go free.

[Davidchan]

I dunno, we are the only server I know with stickyban issues. We either have tons of ban evaders or something isn't setup right.

[John_Oxford]

It's another shitty byond feature, relying on it, even though it does stop the occasional ban evader, causes more harm than good to the player base.

Spoiler:

you could just remove bans all together disregarding ghost role bans and have a super fucking beefy security check point with a ban list next to them, then make security to the point where its a kind of steelpoint-wet-dream level security, and then have them kill people who try to pass who are on the ban list. change the name to something like "deportation list" cheeky lizard immigrants need not apply

[paprika]

I don't think it's a question of freedom, it's a question of how annoying it is to get around

Because ban evaders will always get around this amateur garbage

[Bolien]

Sounds like Papers Please.

[ShadowDimentio]

Which banned person is Gorgi then

[MrStonedOne]

I have a trick up my sleeve to make the game code automatically detect these false positives and revert the stick bans to before the false positives, i've just been busy coding other projects.

I'll try to pop it higher up on my list.

[iamgoofball]

I was thinking of making it reject new stickybans placed within 10 minutes of eachother

[BananaSenor]

I have a trick up my sleeve to make the game code automatically detect these false positives and revert the stick bans to before the false positives, i've just been busy coding other projects.

I'll try to pop it higher up on my list.

Thanks for looking into it.

[Incomptinence]

Well good to know this is being looked into. Seems to be getting more common on my end.

[Armhulen]

i've never been sticky banned, so I think the answer simply is

You just need to get good.

[MrStonedOne]

https://github.com/tgstation/tgstation/pull/19201

basically, if in a round, more than:

2 admins
5 already connected users
10 users

trigger, then it will revert the state of the sticky ban to what it was before round start.

[AnonymousNow]

Banned by host: Whoops guess this guy was evading too. Createbobob

Happened again.

[Super Aggro Crag]

unban anonymousnow, he is my friend.

[yackemflam]

Or add in tarajans and make all tarajans valid

[DemonFiren]

Tajaran.
The term is tajaran.
Or spesskhajiit.

[Jazaen]

The CORRECT term is "target practice", mind.

[oranges]

Everyone send MSO forum pm's about https://github.com/tgstation/tgstation/pull/19201 until he finishes it.