[Penterwast] Angelstarri - Security ban + note appeal

Appeals which have been closed.
Locked
User avatar
angelstarri
Joined: Sun Aug 26, 2018 4:03 am
Byond Username: Angelstarri

[Penterwast] Angelstarri - Security ban + note appeal

Post by angelstarri » #505078

Byond account and character name:

Angelstarri, Pepper Oni

Banning admin:

Penterwast

Ban type (What are you banned from?):

Head of Security, Warden, Detective, Security Officer

Ban reason and length:

1400 minutes - As warden, punched someone into crit who was attacking another player before searching them, then left them to die. The player was at low health and Angelstarri claimed not to have noticed they were in crit.

Time ban was placed (including time zone):
  • Event happened on round 114436
  • Note given on round 114443
  • Note updated twice on round 114447
Server you were playing when banned (Sybil or Bagil):

Bagil

Your side of the story:

I was playing as the Warden on round 114436. There was a traitor with adrenals e-magging doors everywhere throughout the station, so all the Security staff split up to attempt to find him, including me. I was patrolling Science maintenance looking for the traitor then took a turn inside Xenobiology to see if he had run inside. Inside I saw two scientists, one Otto Von Brandt (ckey: GodHandFemto), that was covered in blood, and one Joey Bananas. (ckey: Biwwy) Otto Van Brandt was grabbing Joey aggressively.

I assumed there was a fight going on, so I moved in to break them up by shoving Otto. Otto Von Brandt shoved me back twice. I then assumed that he was hostile. I was unable to use my regular non-lethal Security equipment. My stun baton was too dangerous to use, mainly because the Xenobiology area that we were on was sealed off by firelocks and was dangerously close to several tables and walls that, if I were disarmed, would've resulted in them being able to take the baton. I didn't use my flash, flashbang, and pepper spray because Otto was wearing a gas mask and I didn't know if he had sunglasses under or not. I had a pair of energy and laser guns in my backpack, but I chose not to use them because of the close proximity of walls+tables and the fact that the situation didn't warrant immediate lethal force, so I chose to use a Krav Maga leg sweep as a stopping force.

Unbeknownst to me, Otto had taken damage earlier due to having been shot by a traitor with ballistic guns. I leg swept Otto and punched him a few times to knock him down before using my stun baton to stun him definitely. Joey then ran behind the firelocks that were next to us. I wasn't sure if Otto was a traitor or not, so I searched his pockets and his backpack. He didn't have much aside from several xenobiology items in his backpack and definitely nothing that would warrant him being suspected as a traitor, so I left his stuff on the ground and went back to chasing the e-magger.

Unfortunately, Otto had been brought to critical due to the punches, a fact that I wasn't made aware of until after I was contacted by Penterwast due to there being no indication of it during my stay in the room. The only indicator to this was a gasping emote that was made at 19:43:45.531, something that I couldn't have seen at that time since I was already on the Central Primary Hallway and on the way to the Brig.

This image helps exemplify the state of the room roughly. Note that the image represents DeltaStation as of 2018 and thus is outdated. The small closet north of Xenobio doesn't exist anymore, and there are additional firelocks on the north side of the room which were also closed at the time.

Image

Parsed logs, beginning from when the traitor had shot Otto:

Code: Select all

-- snip -- irrelevant logs before situation happened
-- PART 1: Cotton shoots Otto Von Brandt --
[2019-07-28 19:40:49.434] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [floor] with 10mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (123, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:49.506] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [floor] with 4.6x30mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (123, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:50.090] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [reinforced wall] with 10mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (123, 90, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:50.161] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [reinforced wall] with 4.6x30mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (123, 90, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:50.282] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has shot GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) with 4.6x30mm bullet (NEWHP: 100)  (Research Division (123, 90, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:50.943] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [reinforced wall] with 10mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (123, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:51.011] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [reinforced wall] with 4.6x30mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (123, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:51.077] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has shot GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) with 10mm bullet (NEWHP: 80)  (Research Division (123, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:51.214] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has shot GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) with 4.6x30mm bullet (NEWHP: 50)  (Research Division (123, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:51.614] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [reinforced wall] with 10mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (123, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:51.686] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [reinforced wall] with 4.6x30mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (123, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:52.312] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [floor] with 10mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (124, 91, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:52.314] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has shot *no key*/(Bob) with 10mm bullet (NEWHP: 120)  (Research Division (124, 91, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:52.399] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [floor] with 4.6x30mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (124, 91, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:52.400] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has shot *no key*/(Bob) with 4.6x30mm bullet (NEWHP: 100)  (Research Division (124, 91, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:53.124] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [floor] with 10mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (124, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:53.196] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has fired at [floor] with 4.6x30mm bullet from Research Division (Research Division (124, 89, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:40:53.272] ATTACK: Critscreen2/(Cotton) has shot *no key*/(Bob) with 10mm bullet (NEWHP: 70)  (Research Division (124, 88, 2))

-- snip -- irrelevant logs
-- PART 2: Otto starts aggressively grabbing Joey (attempting to neck grab twice but failing) --
[2019-07-28 19:41:06.101] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has grabbed Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) passive grab (NEWHP: 32)  (Xenobiology Lab (126, 97, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:41:07.919] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has grabbed Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) aggressive grab (NEWHP: 32)  (Xenobiology Lab (123, 97, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:41:14.840] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has attempted to neck grab Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) neck grab (NEWHP: 31)  (Xenobiology Lab (123, 97, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:41:16.572] ATTACK: *no key*/(Bob) has attacked Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) (NEWHP: 31)  (Xenobiology Lab (121, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:41:22.277] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has attempted to neck grab Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) neck grab (NEWHP: 13)  (Xenobiology Lab (113, 97, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:41:38.492] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has grabbed Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) passive grab (NEWHP: 13)  (Xenobiology Lab (108, 96, 2))

-- PART 3: Pepper Oni arrives to the scene --

[2019-07-28 19:41:39.846] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has grabbed Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) aggressive grab (NEWHP: 13)  (Xenobiology Lab (108, 96, 2))
-- FIGHT STARTS --
[2019-07-28 19:41:55.272] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has disarmed (Krav Maga) GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: 30)  (Xenobiology Lab (108, 97, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:41:56.337] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has disarmed (Krav Maga) GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: 30)  (Xenobiology Lab (108, 97, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:41:56.585] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has shoved Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) (NEWHP: 76.7)  (Xenobiology Lab (109, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:02.740] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has shoved Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) (NEWHP: 76.7)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 95, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:06.941] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) has shoved Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) (NEWHP: 76.7)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 94, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:42:08.628] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has leg sweeped GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: 25)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:10.291] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has punched GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: 25)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:10.293] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has stomps on with Krav Maga GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: 10)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:11.338] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has punched GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: 10)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:11.340] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has stomps on with Krav Maga GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: -5)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:12.403] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has punched GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: -5)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:12.405] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has stomps on with Krav Maga GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: -16.2)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:42:18.405] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has stunned GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: -16.2)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))
-- FIGHT ENDS --
-- PART 5: Pepper Oni starts searching Otto Von Brandt, Biwwy starts firing bluespace gun to bypass firelocks but keeps failing --

[2019-07-28 19:42:27.253] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has fired at [reinforced window] with the bluespace beam from Xenobiology Lab (Xenobiology Lab (110, 97, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:42:28.349] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has stripped the science backpack off GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) (NEWHP: -16.2)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 96, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:42:28.532] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has fired at [floor] with the orange bluespace beam from Xenobiology Lab (Xenobiology Lab (110, 97, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:29.972] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has fired at [floor] with the bluespace beam from Xenobiology Lab (Xenobiology Lab (110, 97, 2))

-- PART 6: Pepper Oni finds nothing on Otto Von Brandt and leaves via crowbar to firelock --

[2019-07-28 19:42:33.039] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has fired at [floor] with the orange bluespace beam from Xenobiology Lab (Xenobiology Lab (110, 97, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:42:38.877] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has fired at [floor] with the bluespace beam from Xenobiology Lab (Xenobiology Lab (114, 97, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:42:47.714] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has grabbed *no key*/(blue baby slime (964)) passive grab (NEWHP: 150)  (Xenobiology Lab (115, 102, 2))

-- PART 7: Pepper Oni finds the emagger and starts chasing him throughout Engineering, firing temp gun at them while Biwwy keeps firing the portal gun while grabbing Otto --

[2019-07-28 19:42:48.643] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has fired at [floor] with the freeze beam from Engineering (Engineering (99, 110, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:42:54.063] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has fired at [floor] with the freeze beam from Engineering (Engineering (101, 124, 2))
)
[2019-07-28 19:42:54.746] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has grabbed *no key*/(silver baby slime (883)) passive grab (NEWHP: 150)  (Xenobiology Lab (115, 102, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:42:56.227] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has grabbed *no key*/(blue baby slime (838)) passive grab (NEWHP: 150)  (Xenobiology Lab (115, 102, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:43:05.691] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has grabbed GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) passive grab (NEWHP: -16.9)  (Xenobiology Lab (107, 99, 2))

-- PART 8: Pepper Oni chases emagger through Central Primary Hallway, Otto keeps firing portal gun and grabbing Otto --

[2019-07-28 19:43:25.523] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has fired at [wall] with the freeze beam from Central Primary Hallway (Central Primary Hallway (134, 113, 2))

[2019-07-28 19:43:30.326] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has fired at [air canister] with the orange bluespace beam from Xenobiology Lab (Xenobiology Lab (107, 99, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:43:35.163] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has fired at [floor] with the bluespace beam from Xenobiology Lab (Xenobiology Lab (107, 95, 2))


[2019-07-28 19:43:45.451] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has grabbed GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) passive grab (NEWHP: -17.6)  (Xenobiology Lab (107, 96, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:43:45.531] EMOTE: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) gasps! (Xenobiology Lab (107, 95, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:43:50.138] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) has grabbed GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) passive grab (NEWHP: -18.2)  (Xenobiology Lab (106, 102, 2))

-- PART 9: Pepper Oni loses the suspect, goes to the brig to print stuff from the Security protolathe --
2019-07-28 19:44:39.020] ATTACK: Angelstarri/(Pepper Oni) has thrown the bluespace locator (Brig (201, 145, 2))

-- PART 10: Otto Von Brandt and Joey Bananas die in escape --
[2019-07-28 19:45:01.668] ATTACK: Biwwy/(Joey Bananas) Has succumbed to death while in hard critical with -42.7 points of health! (Departure Lounge (154, 55, 2))
[2019-07-28 19:45:03.903] ATTACK: GodHandFemto/(Otto Von Brandt) Has whispered his final words while in hard critical with -65.1 points of health! (Departure Lounge (154, 55, 2))
I explained to Penterwast everything that I laid out here while expressing regret for what happened. I didn't mean to crit the player, nevermind so kill him. It was an unfortunate coincidence that he was on 30 health before the fight started, a fact that I couldn't have noticed because the whole fight with me and him started and lasted almost 17 seconds where we were both focused on trying to hit each other. The fact that he already had blood on his lab coat and the blood around the room obfuscated the fact that he might've been bleeding after the punches and the only indicator that would've shown me that he was in critical was a whole 15 seconds or so after I had left the room, thus giving me no chance to remedy the situation.

We continued talking on admin help throughout several rounds, where I calmly explained my disagreement with the judgment and also asked for the note to be revised due to the fact that it was very poorly worded to describe the situation in its first iteration. I then notified I'd be appealing the ban and the note.

Why you think you should be unbanned:

The act of critting Otto wasn't intentional. I used the effective tools that I had at my disposal to pacify him as a threat after he started shoving me without incurring additional danger to me or to Joey, who I thought was the victim at the time, with the punches after the leg sweep being an action out of adrenaline more than anything. I apologize profusely to Otto for accidentally killing him, but it was not what I wanted. I was acting on the suspicion that he was attacking Joey and wanted to put a quick stop to the situation so I could get back to stopping the Emagger, but I do not think I acted wrong in this situation at all and only wish that this situation is looked at in the view of what happened instead of the events in hindsight.

The note in question also prejudices against some of my intentions in this community in the future, so I would like to dispute it with the intention of removing it from my record.

Original logs:
https://tgstation13.org/parsed-logs/bas ... attack.txt
https://tgstation13.org/parsed-logs/bas ... 6/game.txt
penterwast
Joined: Sun Apr 15, 2018 1:58 am
Byond Username: Penterwast
Github Username: penterwast

Re: [Penterwast] Angelstarri - Security ban + note appeal

Post by penterwast » #505110

Looking over the logs again, I've decided to remove the ban itself, but not the note. I believe you that you didn't intend to kill them, but the amount of damage done by repeated Krav Maga attacks is not insignificant. I don't feel it is unfair to expect security that are using this sort of force to make sure they are not leaving people in crit if their only intention was to break up a fight and/or perform a search as you stated was the case here.

EDIT: You mentioned that there was no indicator that they were in crit. You can see it on the examine text for players. It gives the message that they are "Barely conscious".
*---------*
This is Ivan Vostok!
He has severe bruising!
He is bleeding!
He is barely conscious.

*---------*
Locked

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users